Back to Blog

Switching Marketing Agencies? A Contractor's Lead Tracking Checklist

PipelineOn Research Team

Before switching agencies, record where each call, form and ad conversion goes. Run the same controlled tests before and after the handoff. Your office should be able to find the test inquiry, see the expected source and name the person responsible for fixing any missing record.

Your tracking number can still ring at dispatch after you switch marketing agencies, while the call stops appearing in the job system. The homeowner gets through, but your office has no record to assign or use to check which campaign brought in the call.

Before the switch, run a test call and form submission through the routes customers already use. After the switch, repeat both tests and check where the records land. If you use Google Ads, check its conversion tracking separately. Put one person from your business in charge of signing off on the results.

Record who controls the routes that bring in leads

Start with your busiest tracking number and quote form. For each, write down where a customer finds it, where it goes and who can change that destination. Include old numbers still printed on trucks, yard signs or mailers. Have a business-side admin sign in and confirm they can see the accounts and settings they need.

Ask both agencies to agree on the switch date, the person making each change and the fallback if a call or form goes missing. Ask the provider what your account can transfer or export. Check the date range and fields in a sample you’re authorized to keep. Store customer records in an approved location and use test details for the handoff checks.

If you’re moving tracking numbers between CallRail accounts, ask support whether they’re moving the entire company record or sending individual numbers to a different company record. CallRail’s transfer instructions call for confirmation from administrators on both sides. Call tags applied to individual calls do not carry over, and the website’s number-swapping script needs updating if the numbers move to a different company in CallRail. Before the move, check whether the call log export includes the columns you need.

Check what changes in Google Ads

Have an Ads admin identify which account owns the conversion action your campaigns use. Google says that if the client uses the outgoing manager’s cross-account conversion tag, the old tag stops measuring conversions from new ad clicks after unlinking. It can still record conversions from clicks that happened before the change, within the conversion window. If the outgoing manager pays through monthly invoicing, have the Ads admin confirm the new billing setup before unlinking. Google’s guide to unlinking manager accounts

For a website conversion, trigger the intended action with Google Tag Assistant. Have the Ads admin check the action and destination account, then check for conversions attributed to clicks after the switch. In Google Ads, the standard conversion columns use the ad interaction date. A debug test verifies the website action. Use the date of the ad interaction to avoid counting a late conversion from a pre-switch click. How Google Ads reports conversion dates

Run the same checks before and after the switch

Pick a time to run the tests with dispatch and the person responsible for tracking. Mark the test records so the office can exclude them from lead and booking totals. Record the time and result at each step.

Here’s a hypothetical example for an HVAC company switching agencies. The owner uses this sheet to decide which part of the handoff is ready.

Test and ownerBefore the switchFirst check after the switchDecision
Call the number printed on the spring tune-up mailer. Office manager owns the test.Dispatch answers. The call log and job system both show the mailer source.Dispatch answers and the call log shows the mailer. The job system has no test lead.Hold this route’s sign-off. Ask the tracking admin to check delivery to the job system. Repeat the call and confirm one lead record with the mailer source and assigned owner.
Submit the quote form with a tagged test visit. Office lead owns the test.Confirmation appears. One inquiry reaches the job system with the expected test campaign.The confirmation, inquiry, campaign and assigned owner match the baseline.Pass. Record the inquiry ID and time.
Trigger the website form conversion. Ads admin owns the test.The agency’s manager account owns the working website action.Tag Assistant shows the intended website action for the new setup. Reporting for new eligible clicks is still pending.Tag check passed. Keep the Ads reporting check open and assign the next review to the Ads admin.

Copy these columns into your handoff sheet and add the account ID or record ID where you checked each result. If customers use multiple numbers, schedulers or forms, repeat the checks for the routes the change affects. The call and form tracking guide explains what each system can record.

Have the business-side owner review open issues with the agencies before ending any agreed overlap. In the example, the mailer number is still useful for callers, so dispatch can log its calls in the job system while the tracking admin fixes delivery. Any temporary process should have an owner, an end date and a repeat test before the office relies on automation again.

PipelineOn

Enter your work email to get started

Already have an account? Sign in